Cuban dissidents criticize Havana bishops’ letter on Cardinal Jaime Ortega
Posted on Sunday, 06.03.12
Cuban dissidents criticize Havana bishops' letter on Cardinal Jaime Ortega
Cuban dissidents took exception to a letter by Havana's Bishops Council
that denounced a campaign to discredit the archbishop of Havana.
By Juan Carlos Chavez
Members of the opposition inside Cuba openly criticized the content of a
letter sent recently by representatives of the Cuban Catholic Church's
hierarchy in support of Cardinal Jaime Ortega Alamino, archbishop of Havana.
The letter was signed by bishops and vicars of Havana's Bishops Council.
In three paragraphs, the text denounced what they call a campaign to
discredit Ortega and his efforts to improve the national situation.
Martha Beatriz Roque, spokesperson of the banned Cuban Network of
Community Communicators, denied dissidents were being malicious. She
said criticism of Ortega's role was based on concrete facts.
"We simply believe that the dialogue headed by Ortega was not done with
dignity nor did it follow Christ's doctrine," Roque told El Nuevo Herald
in a phone interview. "Had it been so, we would all be involved in that
dialogue process. The Catholic hierarchy bowed their head before the
regime and turned their back on the opposition."
Under Ortega's leadership, and with the support of the Spanish
government, the Catholic Church initiated a round of historic and
far-reaching meetings with Cuban President Raúl Castro in May 2010. The
dissidents were not invited to that dialogue despite repeated requests.
The result was the gradual and conditioned release of more than 130
prisoners, including 52 activists and independent journalists of the
Group of 75, sentenced in 2003 during a repressive wave known as the
"Black Spring." Most of them had to go directly from prison to the
airport and fly to Spain.
Exiles encouraged more than a hundred dissidents, such as Roque and
Jorge Luis García "Antúnez," Guillermo Fariñas and Vladimiro Roca, to
send an open letter in August 2010 to Pope Benedict XVI harshly
protesting the role the church's hierarchy has played in the release of
A year later, the pope announced the Vatican's decision to keep Cardinal
Ortega, who had submitted his resignation on Oct. 18 upon turning 75, in
The debate over Ortega's handling of the prisoners' releases and the
rights of civil society recently intensified. In an April 24 forum at
Harvard University's David Rockefeller Center of Latin American Studies
in Cambridge, Mass., Ortega called 13 opponents of the banned Republican
Party for Cuba "criminals."
The 13 occupied a church in Havana before they were pushed, beaten and
kicked out of the church, according to Vladimir Calderón, director of
the banned Republican Party. They were thrown out shortly before the
pope's visit to Cuba at the end of March.
Calderón told El Nuevo Herald on Saturday that the content of the
bishops' letter supporting Cardinal Ortega mischaracterizes the position
of the internal dissidence.
The bishops who signed the letter are the six members of the Bishops
Council. Among them are auxiliary bishops, Msgr. Alfredo Petit and Juan
de Dios Hernández. Vicars Msgr. Carlos Manuel de Céspedes, Ramón Suárez
Polcari and Rodolfo Loiz also signed.
"No one has tried to discredit the cardinal at any time," Calderón said
from his home in Havana. "The work he has done in the church has been
criticized because we have not seen a recognition of the importance of
The bishops' statement supporting Ortega highlighted that the campaign
to discredit him not only criticizes the cardinal's complex pastoral
performance, but it also, the statement said, attempts to "abort" any
effort toward an understanding and dialogue pursuing a calm, beneficial
solution to Cuba's human rights conflict.
In Santa Clara, Fariñas, winner of the European Parliament's 2010
Sakharov Award, said that it has been Ortega who discredited himself by
the nature and direction of his actions.
"His attitude against peaceful opposition is shameful," Fariñas said.
"Ortega should act as a friend of God and not of Castro's regime."
Ortega has met several times with Castro. He has interceded before him
on behalf of the Ladies in White, as well as of more than 130 political
prisoners released in 2010 and 2011.
Berta Soler, leader of the ladies' group, rejected the idea that the
opposition wants to damage Ortega's image and seeks to prevent any
effort toward a dialogue dealing with the current Cuban situation.
"I am sure that there is no such campaign to discredit, much less
against the church," Soler said in Havana. "The Ladies in White do not
wish to discredit the cardinal and are not going to do it. All we ask
now is to listen to us and to give continuity to the Catholic doctrine."
The letter from the bishops was released Friday afternoon by Orlando
Márquez, spokesperson of the Archdiocese of Havana.
After some critics accused Ortega of aligning himself with the Cuban
government, two Catholic magazines defended him in May. The president of
the Cuban Parliament, Ricardo Alarcón, also joined in and referred to
the criticism against Ortega as "vulgar attacks" and "insidious campaigns."
ALLEGIANCE IN DOUBT
Dissident Andrés Carrión said that Ortega has "radicalized" a situation
that should be fluid. Carrión was the man who screamed "Freedom!" and
"Down with communism!" as well as other anti-Castro slogans on March 26,
shortly before the pope's Mass at Antonio Maceo Square in Santiago de
Cuba. "We have no interest in launching a campaign of lies or
discredit," Carrión told El Nuevo Herald. "In any event, I believe that
Ortega should be closer to the oppressed and more distant from the
powerful and the dictatorship."
Dagoberto Valdez, a renowned activist and director of the digital
magazine Convivencia, opted to put aside the controversy. He said that
there are other issues that deserve attention. "Now the most important
issues are the problems in Cuba and its government's inefficiency to